Broader definition needed for Tucson to be able to solve the problems
it will face in the coming year
What is southern Arizona's most pressing problem?
Prison growth? Slow economic development?
Droves of uninsured children? The need for alternative energy sources?
All of these
and more?
Tucson could become one of the most attractive, livable and innovative
U.S. cities, but the challenges are overwhelming.
In the Greater Tucson Leadership
spring 2007 class, 33 of us learned what changes the region is experiencing and
what its future may hold.
What will it take to improve our education and transportation
systems while strengthening industry, government and many other areas?
Leaders,
I'm told.
But who are they?
Wealthy men dressed in sharp business suits with swanky
ties and leather shoes? Presidents, CEOs, executives, club members and those with
impressive academic titles?
Not necessarily.
Those things don't always denote leadership
qualities or care for the community.
"We've gotten away from the other question,
'Who are the 10 most influential people?' There is no such thing," said Tom Volgy,
a University of Arizona political science professor and former Tucson mayor.
"They
existed in the 1950s, if they existed, and people have been looking for them since,"
Volgy said.
"What we've ended up with, for good or bad - I think it's for the good
- is a revolving leadership that varies a lot with the nature of the problem."
I
side with Volgy.
Leadership is not a matter of membership or the power of one, and
it requires strides toward improving the human condition.
Sounds a lot like Greater
Tucson Leadership (GTL) values.
It also sounds somewhat counter to our national
value of self-determinism - one I believe can diminish a person's ability to be
an effective leader.
"There is an emerging sense that leadership should be broader,"
said Michael McDonald, executive director of Habitat for Humanity in Tucson. "It
calls to the deepest part of us all to do things that are countercultural and counterintuitive."
What would happen otherwise? We've heard the stories:
"So-and-so said she's volunteering
this weekend so she can put it on her résumé."
Or, "Mr. Whoever has donated a couple
thousand dollars again. He said his name had better be in bold print on the donors
list this year. And he's hoping for that huge tax break.
"Self-determination, eh?
What happened to impassioned work toward justice and equality for all?
"Good leaders
really understand that it is about making the quality of life better for others
- before themselves," said Tucson Mayor Bob Walkup.
Granted, good work happens when
one person can rally others around a cause. And many organizations are in desperate
need of donor dollars.
But it's not enough to hand over a check or sit silently
on a board.
GTL teaches that leaders must be more involved and engaged. Face-time,
open ears, passion and the ability to build coalitions are critical.
So are strides
toward improving the human condition - and that goes for the public and private
sectors.
The hard part will be to convince the old school, because humanitarian
efforts can be difficult to quantify, especially from a capitalist view.
Try putting
into real numbers the value of the person who stands up against outmoded legislation
or who lobbies his employer to provide men with maternity leave.
What about the
couple who adopt abused children or mentors who show wayward teens they're worth
more than being drug addicts or youths affiliated with gangs?
"It's about doing
the right thing when nobody else is watching and practicing principles and leadership
and demonstrating integrity," said former U.S. Surgeon General Richard Carmona.
Still not motivated? Consider our children and youth. It is not fair to rob them
of health, happiness or a future.
And stop celebrating people who lead without purpose.
Recognize creative, innovative thinkers who are fixing problems and breaking down
disparities.
But remember: No person has all the ideas or even the ability to solve
what are often complex and deeply rooted problems.
Didn't we learn all of this in
kindergarten? What happened as we grew up? We began to lose our humanity.
Why else
would we have so many problems?
GTL is about restoring the human spirit around community
and action.
My class shadowed teachers, visited the Legislature and learned about
the emergence of telemedicine in rural areas, the origins of mariachi music and
solar energy use downtown.
We also peeked into small living spaces and walked in
the social quarters of criminals at the state prison complex.
Some days, we had
tremendous fun. Others were the serious sort that provided a sense of urgency about
issues affecting Tucson and southern Arizona.
It was the most comprehensive education
many of us had ever received.
The spring 2007 class graduated May 30 and was left
with the charge to do something.
I ask, what will you do?
Defining a leader
"Leadership
is finding out what is now or will be missing, assessing how much could be done
to improve it and how, persuading enough people to act on it, relentlessly evaluating
whether the solution is getting the job done and continually trying to position
yourself, your group (or) your institution to ensure that those gaps are filled,
even if by someone else." - Scott Stewart, Pima Community College Board of Governors
member
"The person who intentionally creates and sustains an interpersonal environment
where everyone feels safe, trusted, esteemed and unconditionally loved and respected
is a leader." - Stephanie Parker, Aurora Foundation president and founder
"When
you start making decisions that are self-serving, then you're a bad leader. We have
a lot of those people who get thrust into positions of leadership and the ego gets
involved." - Pima County Sheriff Clarence W. Dupnik
"In the political arena, I find
very few people really standing out as leaders. You think of the leadership during
the time of the (U.S.) Constitution, the Civil War, the Cold War and World War II
- where are those leaders today? Part of it is that people tend to think of political
office as trying to get themselves re-elected rather than trying to do something
good." - Former U.S. Rep. Jim Kolbe "
A leader is constantly coaching employees to
excel and further their potential, which oftentimes extends beyond the potential
of the leader. If I hired my staff to my ability or less, there wouldn't be that
multiplier effect where one plus one equals four.
"You always try to find people
who have talents beyond yours. That's sometimes a hard thing to do because ego sometimes
gets in the way." - Tomás León, president and CEO of the Tucson Hispanic Chamber
of Commerce
EDITORIAL: You – yes, you – need to be a leader
WHAT'S NEEDED: All it
takes is an hour a month